- An appraisal determines the market value of a property using comparable sales and property data, often for lenders.
- A home inspection assesses the physical condition of the property—structure, systems, defects—for the buyer’s benefit.
- Appraisals protect lenders from over-lending; inspections protect buyers from costly surprises.
- In most real estate transactions, both are used to reduce risk and empower negotiations.
When buying a home, you’ll often hear terms like “appraisal” and “home inspection” thrown around. Many buyers—and sometimes sellers—confuse them, thinking they serve the same purpose. But mixing them up can lead to costly misunderstandings: an appraisal might arrive lower than expected, or an inspection might uncover major repair issues you didn’t budget for. As a real estate professional team, we’ve helped dozens of clients navigate both processes in Nanaimo and BC. In this article, you’ll clearly understand what each one does, how they differ, and why you usually need both to truly protect your investment.
What exactly is a home appraisal and why is it needed?
- An appraisal is a professional’s unbiased estimate of a property’s fair market value, based on data, condition, and comparables.
- Lenders require appraisals to confirm that the property is worth the amount being financed (so they don’t loan more than the home is worth).
- Appraisers look at:
• Comparable sales (nearby similar homes)
• Location, lot size, view, neighborhood trends
• Condition of structure, major features, deferred maintenance
Because an appraisal affects whether a mortgage is approved (or its terms), it’s a critical step in financed home purchases.
What does a home inspection do and who orders it?
- A home inspection is a detailed evaluation of a home’s current condition—structure, systems (plumbing, electrical, HVAC), roof, foundation, and more.
- It is usually initiated by the buyer, not the lender. The buyer hires a certified inspector.
- During the inspection, the inspector:
• Documents defects, wear, safety concerns with photos
• States whether systems are functioning (or nearing end of life)
• May comment on life expectancy of components (roof, water heater)
The inspection gives buyers clarity about hidden problems, needed repairs, or safety issues—before the deal is finalized.
How do appraisal and inspection differ — side by side?
How do appraisal and inspection differ — side by side?
Purpose & audience
- Appraisal → serves lenders and the financing process; ensures the home’s value supports the loan.
- Inspection → serves the buyer; reveals physical defects, safety risks, and needed repairs.
Scope & methods
- Appraiser does a walkthrough and uses external data + comps; less depth on every system.
- The inspector goes room by room, tests systems, looks under floors/roofs (where accessible).
Timing & cost
- Inspection often occurs right after offer acceptance, within the conditional period.
- Appraisal is ordered by the lender during processing of the mortgage.
- Cost-wise, both typically run hundreds of dollars, depending on home size & location.
Outcome & legal / contractual implications
- An appraisal can lead to renegotiation if it comes in lower than the agreed purchase price.
- A home inspection can trigger repair requests, credits, or withdrawal (if contingency included).
Some contracts include both inspection contingencies and appraisal contingencies.
Do you always need both?
Yes, in most cases it’s wise to include both:
- Appraisal is almost always required by mortgage lenders.
- Inspection is not always required by lenders—but is strongly recommended to protect your investment.
- Skipping inspection may save money up front but carry great risk of hidden costs later.
In sum: appraisal = value assurance, inspection = condition assurance. Both are critical.
What happens if the appraisal is low or inspection reveals issues?
Low appraisal
- The lender may refuse to fund a full loan based on the agreed sale price.
- The buyer and seller may need to renegotiate the price, or buyer may bring extra cash.
- Some buyers appeal the appraisal by presenting additional comps or arguing methodology.
Inspection issues
- The buyer may ask the seller to repair defects or reduce the price (credit).
- If the contract has an inspection contingency, the buyer can walk away penalty-free.
- Some issues may require specialized inspections (e.g. mold, foundation) before proceeding.
Understanding the difference between an appraisal and a home inspection is essential to avoid pitfalls during a home purchase. The appraisal protects lenders and confirms value; the inspection protects buyers by revealing the home’s true condition. In a transaction, both tools work together to reduce risk and enable informed decisions.
If you’re buying a home in Nanaimo (or in BC) and need help coordinating reliable appraisers or inspectors—or want expert guidance through the entire process—the Scott Parker Real Estate Team is here to help. Contact us today, and let’s make your home purchase smarter, safer, and smoother.
Subscribe here to our newsletter for insider tips, checklists, and local market insights.
FAQ Section
Q: Can a seller refuse a home inspection?
A: Yes—if you didn’t include an inspection contingency in your offer, the seller can deny it. But in most buyer offers, one includes the right to inspect before finalizing.
Q: Who pays for the appraisal vs. inspection?
A: Usually the buyer pays both. The lender arranges the appraisal, and the buyer hires the inspector directly.
Q: Which should come first — the inspection or appraisal?
A: Typically, the inspection comes first (right after offer acceptance), so buyers can negotiate or withdraw before appraisal and closing.
Q: What happens if appraisal is less than the offer price?
A: Buyer and seller may renegotiate, buyer might pay the difference in cash, or the deal may fall through if terms cannot be met.
Q: Is a home inspection mandatory?
A: Not legally, but it’s strongly recommended. Many buyers refuse to waive the inspection because it can expose hidden defects.